Plant based milk headlines come every few months. The Telegraph wrote a couple of articles about plant based milk nutrition, and how that can affect to people who consume plant based diet or not. Each time vegan and plant based defenders the answer is been the same nutrition defense like we can see in all this webs articles.

Foodfacts (6): rated a Telegraph plant-milk headline misleading in January 2025 (updated 2 Oct 2026)

Viva (7): Media coverage of misleading headlines on plant milks for young children 5 May 2026

Vegan Society (8): The allergy society report (BSACI) on plant drinks for children, through a statement by its dietitian 6 May 2026

Let's get closer and analyze the article from Telegraph

From all people were analysed (3,095 of 3,558), been excluded who ate no dairy (2), that mean people who have plant based diet or taking plant based milk with no dairy never been studied. In this studied only appeared people who ate dairy, and plant based products just been swap on paper (2). That means the newspaper misleading the headline "Dropping milk to go vegan is bad for you, study warns" (1), though no vegans was been studied and the researchers never mention vegans.

Full study been realized in base of computer modelling (2), that mean nobody change the diet, no health outcomes or another analyses was measured. They just swap dairy foods been in people's food diaries for plant based products picked in supermarkets survey's.

But let's focus on what the study found; with mandatory fortification of plant alternatives in four nutrients (iodine, calcium, B2 and B12) at the EU "source of" minimum in the model, mean intakes did not drop at any level of replacement (only B12 dipped a bit in some groups, with no rise in people falling short) and with iodine in both plant alternatives and bread, iodine adequacy was kept or improved in every age group, even at 100% dairy replacement (2).

But at the same time we need to give some credibility for study too, like study's own best scenario fully replaces dairy without losing iodine adequacy. Mention too that Dairy's iodine mostly comes from farm supplements (2) (5). But most important we need to focus that UK government advisers already wrote the spec in July 2025 (3) what plant based drinks ( milk's ) should carry. And now this study warns too that voluntary fortification is not enough, so knowing that we see how the market lags of the specs (2) (4).

Now that we know that UK government advisers recommended Plant drinks should be fortified with vitamin A, riboflavin, vitamin B12, calcium and iodine at comparable levels to semi-skimmed cows milk (3).

But is that really true that we compare to cows milk just like that, because in the 2016 to 2019 survey years the study used, 54% of girls aged 14 to 18 (2) was already below the iodine requirement on their diet, dairy included. How we really try to compare booth's side having similar issues and not mention that iodine given in feed and mineral supplements is the biggest driver of milk iodine (5). Plus knowing that In the Netherlands and New Zealand (4), UK fortified plant milks may hold more iodine than local cow's milk, that means milk iodine depends on how a country farms. With all this we can see intake gap is real iodine above all.

And at the same time we need to mention that for the study been select very specific surveys and exclusive years from older market data (2) (4) that not mean is not true.

My strongest question here is why we still answering to all this kind articles with the same nutrition claims in defense, where i taking in consideration of UK advisers recommendations that plant based drinks ( milks ) should be fortified. If we exactly know the rule that would narrow the existing gap and stop it growing, why fix still is not required. Even with organic plant based drinks, that been 16% of supermarket plant milks in 2024 (and 28% in 2020) (4), by EU and GB organic rules they not allowed to add vitamins and minerals by choice, only when the law require it (9) (10). UK advisers say the same and note that manufacturers told them the law stop them to add iodine (3), and only a legal minimum rule would let organic drinks carry iodine too. That's where we should start, stand up and demand from the UK government consider setting minimum requirements because right now no legal or minimum composition standards exist for plant drinks (3).

Here are the links and studies i used for check all this:

(1) Telegraph article "Dropping milk to go vegan is bad for you, study warns" from 4 Nov 2026: telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/04/dropping-dairy-milk-to-go-vegan-is-bad-for-you-study-warns/ (subscription), free copy on Yahoo: health.yahoo.com/wellness/nutrition/articles/dropping-dairy-milk-vegan-bad-223000227.html

(2) The study in Lancet Planetary Health 2026 (10: 101515) from University of Surrey, Queen's University Belfast and University College Dublin at doi.org/10.1016/j.lanplh.2026.101515

(3) UK advisers SACN and COT report on plant based drinks from July 2025 on gov.uk

(4) Market survey on plant alternative fortification over five years in British Journal of Nutrition 2026 at doi.org/10.1017/S0007114526106758

(5) Dairy science review on iodine from feed to milk in Journal of Dairy Science 2023 at doi.org/10.3168/jds.2022-22599

(6) Foodfacts check on the January 2025 Telegraph headline on foodfacts.org

(7) Viva article "Plant milks: more misleading headlines" from 5 May 2026 on viva.org.uk

(8) The Vegan Society statement "The truth about plant milks" from 6 May 2026 on vegansociety.com

(9) EU organic rule Regulation (EU) 2018/848 Annex II Part IV 2.2.2(f) on eur-lex.europa.eu

(10) GB organic rule Regulation (EC) No 889/2008 Article 27(1)(f) on legislation.gov.uk

First published as a Field Note on my website: https://justinasbuilds.com/blog/plant-milk-fix-not-required