Update, 20 November 2026: the official records I cited in my letters to the three offices this article wrote to, with each office's reply status at the deadline, are the first three entries of my ledger: https://justinasbuilds.com/blog/un-records-on-diets-and-livestock

I checked the 2025 methane report the Call cites. Its 72/18/10 split of modelled technical potential for 2030 matches the Call. That same report also models diet change in a separate Demand scenario. I did not find that scenario in the saved Call's searchable text.

Over the last years, every time a UN climate meeting was organized I used to get very excited, because I thought things could change faster if we all agreed on the same point, and I always thought saving lives is good for everyone, including our climate and nature when it comes to the gases we put into our atmosphere. I got more and more interested in each UN speech and document, and like I mentioned in my recent articles, certain things started catching my attention much more closely. At first the progress looked good when the Secretary-General launched the Call to Action on Methane in June 2026 (according to his 11 November remarks), with a cover reading "Three sectors, nine actions by 2030". In the executive summary on page 03, the Call states very important points: "Agriculture is the largest source of anthropogenic methane emissions", and "Livestock contributes about one-third of all anthropogenic methane" (with no source listed in the executive summary for that figure). Because fossil fuel mitigation technologies are "mature, rapidly deployable and cost-effective", it concludes that "this sector must deliver the majority of near-term methane reductions." The next sentence adds: "But action must also accelerate across agriculture and waste." At first glance all of this sounds really good and looks like things are moving in the right direction.

Where the 72% comes from

Let's analyze the numbers and data together. On page 08, the Call gives its main split: "If all technically feasible measures were implemented, 72 per cent of the total 2030 mitigation potential lies in the fossil fuel sector, 18 per cent in the agriculture sector and 10 per cent in the waste sector." That paragraph has one footnote, placed after the next sentence, beginning "UNEP Global Methane Status Report 2025." When I opened that report from the UN Environment Programme (UNEP) and the Climate and Clean Air Coalition, it gave the same 72 / 18 / 10 split for the energy, agriculture and waste sectors.

Someone might stop and ask what is going on here: we just read on page 03 that agriculture is the largest producer of human-caused methane with about one-third coming from livestock, yet on page 08 fossil fuels show up at 72% and agriculture at only 18%. The reason is what that 72 / 18 / 10 split actually measures. In the 2025 report, the split comes from a technical scenario that "assesses the impact of maximum technically feasible reduction, through implementation of more than 40 existing methane control technologies". So 72% is the energy sector's share of modelled technical mitigation potential in 2030, not who produces the most methane and not an allocation of planned cuts. And diet change is modelled in a separate scenario.

When you look at the livestock digestion (enteric fermentation) numbers in that same report, you see why technology alone barely moves the needle. For 2030, the report projects 112 million tonnes a year of methane from livestock digestion under current laws. Using existing technical fixes, the modelled reduction potential is only 7 million tonnes per year in 2030, rising to 16 million tonnes per year in 2040 (including the full effect of breeding measures begun before 2030). Those reductions are small compared with the 112 million tonnes a year projected under current laws by 2030.

What the same report says next

When we keep analyzing that same 2025 report, we see it does not stop at technology. Its executive summary warns clearly: "After 2030, targeted technical mitigation options alone will not be sufficient to reduce methane emissions to levels consistent with climate and development goals." Because of that, the report models a separate "Demand" scenario that adds diet shifts and less food waste on top of those technical measures. And when you combine all of them into one combined route, the report's key messages say that full technical measures, "combined with parallel efforts to both decarbonize the global energy system and implement demand-side measures, targeted at human dietary changes and reducing the generation of food waste, could deliver a reduction of 53 per cent by 2050, consistent with 1.5°C pathways." Its executive summary gives the baseline: "53 per cent reduction below 2020 levels".

What the Call carries, and what it does not

When I searched all 28 pages of the searchable text extracted from the saved Call, it made me look at the whole thing from a very different angle. It made me focus on what is inside those pages and what is not, and honestly the clearest place to start is with what I did not find there. Inside the searchable text of that saved 28-page Call, I did not find the warning that technical options "alone will not be sufficient", I did not find the separate Demand scenario, and I did not find that combined 53% route (a possible, not guaranteed, 53% reduction in annual methane emissions by 2050 below 2020 levels). On top of that, a case-insensitive whole-word search finds "diet" 0 times, "meat" 0 times, and "herd" 0 times. "Dairy" appears twice, in a project example from India, and "livestock" appears 9 times.

Now that I have shown what I did not find, let's also look fairly at what I did find in the Call about food and farming. It does include specific actions on food and farms: Action 5 says "Halve per-capita food waste and reduce food loss", Action 4 asks to "Scale up proven methane-reducing practices in livestock and rice production with dedicated support for smallholder farmers", and Action 6 in the executive summary's action list asks to align subsidies and finance "with methane-reducing production systems and consumption". When you read those actions closely, you can see the approach is quite different from the 53% combined route in the 2025 report. The Call does mention a 2050 number of its own. Citing the IPCC, it says global methane emissions "would have to fall around 34 per cent by 2030 and 51 per cent by 2050 relative to 2019 levels", which is a different figure, from a different source, against a different base year, not the 2025 report's 53% route.

The reasons and timing on record

I am not here to guess anyone's motives behind the reasons or the timing they chose to follow. What the Call itself explains on page 18 (section 5.2) is that it wants to focus first on a phase prioritizing productivity and optimization until 2030, especially in developing countries: "A phased approach prioritizing productivity and optimization until 2030 – particularly in developing countries where reduction potential is highest – can unlock near-term gains while building the trust and evidence base for deeper structural shifts." Checking the Call multiple times, I did not find a timetable or an assigned office specifically for those "deeper structural shifts" they talk about building toward.

Going back to the 2025 report, its Demand scenario sets out its own timing right beside this: "As demand-side changes are typically slow, impacts on emissions are assumed from 2040 onward, provided measures start in the pre-2030 period." According to that same report, diet measures already written into national climate plans are counted in a different scenario ("Current NDCs and MAPs"), while the Call's nine actions are set "by 2030". What neither saved document actually tells the public is why those demand-side elements are not in the Call. A text copy of the UN's methane web page (saved on 13 November) says the Call was "Developed by the UN Secretary-General’s Climate Action Team in collaboration with UN partners and leading institutions", and neither the saved Call nor that saved web page points to any published draft, consultation record or terms of reference showing how the content was decided.

Two COP31 speeches on 11 November 2026

As COP31 nears its scheduled closing day, it also helps to look at two COP31 speeches the Secretary-General gave in Antalya on 11 November 2026. At the leaders' roundtable on methane, he pushed hard for a new rule on fossil fuels, saying: "That is why I have called for a global near-zero methane standard for oil and gas." He went right on to say: "Today, I am asking the United Nations Environment Programme to develop it." Later in that same speech, when talking about food, he said: "That means halving food waste by 2030." When I checked the saved texts of that roundtable speech and his COP31 Leaders' Summit speech from the same day, neither contains any of the words livestock, meat, dairy, diet or diets (the roundtable only mentions organic waste becoming "animal feed"). You can check my full count of 14 selected speeches and the method here: https://justinasbuilds.com/blog/what-14-un-speeches-name

Counterexamples

To be fair, the Secretary-General has named meat and dairy before. Back at the C40 World Mayors Summit in Copenhagen on 11 October 2019, he said: "Food consumption is responsible for 13 per cent of greenhouse gas emissions in C40 cities, with meat and dairy consumption making up 75 per cent of that total." Those numbers are about C40 cities, not the whole world. In my view, that brings us back to a fair point: it is not fair to put more pressure on countries dealing with harder problems or less capacity to act, and at the same time we should not assume developing countries cannot lead either, because in many areas some are doing a much better job than developed countries.

What this shows, and why I wrote to the offices

Putting the 72 / 18 / 10 split right next to what I did not find in the Call pages, I am not here trying to guess who decided what went in, or why those passages are not there. That is exactly why I sent written questions to all three offices whose documents this article quotes, giving them a fair opportunity to explain themselves, show me if I got anything wrong, or even catch mistakes I made, so I can deliver the most honest version the documents and public data allow without guessing.

Questions and replies

On 16 November 2026, at about 08:26 UTC, I sent written questions to the three offices whose documents this article quotes. I asked for replies by Thursday 19 November 2026, 18:00 UTC. That is a short window, during COP31, and I said so openly in the letters. I published all the questions on 17 November: https://justinasbuilds.com/blog/questions-to-26-offices

Office of the Spokesperson for the Secretary-General. Among my questions: "What was the reason for not including that report's diet and food-waste ("Demand") scenario, its combined pathway of technical measures, energy decarbonization, dietary shifts and less food waste (projected to reduce annual methane emissions in 2050 by 53% below 2020 levels), or its statement that after 2030 technical options "alone will not be sufficient"?" And: "Which document records who decided the content of the Call to Action (a draft, terms of reference or consultation record)? Will you release it?"

Reply: No reply had arrived by the deadline, Thursday 19 November 2026, 18:00 UTC.

UN Environment Programme (UNEP), News and Media Unit and International Methane Emissions Observatory. Among my questions: "What evidence supports counting the effects of the additional Demand scenario's diet and food-waste measures only "from 2040 onward"? Who decided that timing, and which document records the decision?"

Reply: No reply had arrived by the deadline, Thursday 19 November 2026, 18:00 UTC.

Climate and Clean Air Coalition Secretariat. Among my questions: "Was there a formal approval process for the report's scenarios, including the additional Demand scenario? If so, who approved them, and were the Board or the Champions asked to approve them?"

Reply: No reply had arrived by the deadline, Thursday 19 November 2026, 18:00 UTC.

Replies received after the deadline will be added, with the date each one was added.

Limits

  • "Not found" means not found by a word search of the searchable text in a saved copy of the Call. Words inside images are not covered.
  • The 72%, the tonnes (112, 7 and 16) and the 53% are model results, not measurements.
  • The 14 speeches are my selection, not everything the Secretary-General has said.
  • Quotations were checked against the saved copies identified in the source sheet; one web source survives as a text copy, and live pages can change.
  • If you catch a mistake, write to me at j.cekanauskas@justinasbuilds.com and I will correct it here, with the date.

How I work

I write in my own voice and publish independently under my own name. I run my own solo research lab using custom scripts and AI verification checks to dig through data and cross-check public documents, list the sources behind every fact so anyone can check my work, and take responsibility for every word and correction.

Sources

The source sheet links every documentary claim and quotation to its official source and records the search methods and limits: https://justinasbuilds.com/blog/diet-change-not-in-methane-call-sources

Justinas Čekanauskas · justinasbuilds.com